| #4 | Baldwin Wallace | (6,4) | -0.792 | -0.592 |
| #9 | Capital | (1,9) | -0.730 | -1.530 |
| #5 | Heidelberg | (6,4) | -0.914 | -0.714 |
| #2 | John Carroll | (8,2) | -0.758 | -0.158 |
| #3 | Marietta | (8,2) | -0.853 | -0.253 |
| #1 | Mount Union | (11,1) | -0.860 | -0.026 |
| #7 | Muskingum | (4,6) | -0.857 | -1.057 |
| #6 | Ohio Northern | (4,6) | -0.714 | -0.914 |
| #10 | Otterbein | (0,10) | -0.745 | -1.745 |
| #8 | Wilmington | (3,7) | -0.819 | -1.219 |